Soft Creamy Caramel Popcorn Recipe (2024)

Hello my name is Sarah, I am married to a caramel popcorn snob. Well snob is kind of harsh, maybe I should call him a caramel popcorn critic. Yes that sounds nicer. I grew up making Caramel popcorn in a bagwhich turns out nice and crunchy, just the way I like it. My husband however is not a fan of crunchy caramel corn, he likesSoft Creamy Caramel Popcorn. ButSoft Creamy Caramel Popcorn scares me because it can pull a filling out of your tooth if you are not careful. Some recipes are TOO sticky, while others leave the popcorn almost soggy.

I am excited to share this recipe with you, it gets the thumbs up and approval from my husband. My kids all love it, best part is it is super easy too make too. Hope you enjoy this recipe forSoft Creamy Caramel Popcorn as much as we do!

Soft Creamy Caramel Popcorn Recipe (1)

Soft Creamy Caramel Popcorn Recipe

What you need:

  • 14 oz can of Sweetened Condensed Milk
  • 1 stick of butter (1/2 a cup)
  • 1 cup brown sugar firmly packed
  • 10 oz bag of mini marshmallows
  • 1/2 teaspoon baking soda
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla
  • 24 cups of popcorn

Tools I like to use for this recipe:

Soft Creamy Caramel Popcorn Recipe (2)

Directions:

You will need to pop 24 cups of popcorn. We love to use our Stir Crazy popcorn popperit gives the popcorn a great flavor and crunchy texture. We do add a pinch of salt to each batch, but do not butter it. But you can use plain or buttered popcorn for this recipe, we just prefer plain. Once you have popped your popcorn, measure out 24 cups and set aside while you make the caramel sauce. I would recommend fluffing your popcorn to try and get all the corn kernels that did not pop to sink to the bottom. Toss those in the trash, so you don’t bust your tooth on them (yes my husband has done that more than once).

This makes a BIG batch of popcorn, 24 cups. I love theThatsa Mega Tupperware Bowlfor this recipe. It is big enough to hold everything and allows me to stir and mix without popcorn falling out over the sides.

In aSauce pot 6 quartor larger add your sweetened Condensed Milk, butter, brown sugar and marshmallows. Over medium heat stir still they are well blended and just come to a low boil. Normally takes about 6-7 minutes. Make sure you do this over medium heat if your temperature is too high your sugar will not dissolve which gives you a gritty texture. I always stir the whole time to prevent scorching the butter and milk.

Once it has come to a low boil, take off heat. Stir in your vanilla (pure vanilla is best) and sprinkle in the baking soda. Do this in a dusting motion so you do not get a big clump of baking soda in your caramel sauce. Be aware that the baking soda will cause your caramel sauce to double in size and become soft, almost foamy. Stir in well then quickly pour over the popcorn you have waiting for you in a bowl.

It will be a bit sticky so I recommend using aSilicone spatula to mix it all together really well. DO NOT try to eat it right away because it is hot! Give it a few minutes to cool down. You can eat it right out of the bowl. Or you can pour it onto aAluminum Commercial Baker’s Half Sheet. Then as it cools you can cut it into Soft Creamy Caramel Popcorn squares. You can also shape them into Soft Creamy Caramel Popcorn balls.

The caramel is super soft at first this is our favorite time to eat it. After an hour or so it starts to firm up and is still soft, just more like a soft and chewy rice crispy treat that will hold its shape. But still soft and you can easily pull it apart and eat it. It really is amazing! I love that you can make it a few days before an event and it is still delicious!

Try thisSoft Creamy Caramel Popcorn Recipe out, let me know what you think. I hope you enjoy it as much as my family does! Perfect for large groups or family movie night!

Watch our Recipe Video

Soft Creamy Caramel Popcorn Recipe (3)

Soft Creamy Caramel Popcorn Recipe

Soft Creamy Caramel Popcorn Recipe (4)

  • Soft Creamy Caramel Popcorn Recipe
  • What you need:
  • 14 oz can of Sweetened Condensed Milk
  • 1 stick of butter (1/2 a cup)
  • 1 cup brown sugar firmly packed
  • 10 oz bag of mini marshmallows
  • 1/2 teaspoon baking soda
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla
  • 24 cups of popcorn
  • Tools I like to use for this recipe:
  • Stir Crazy popcorn popper
  • Aluminum Commercial Baker's Half Sheet
  • Silicone spatula
  • Sauce pot 6 quart
  • Thatsa Mega Tupperware Bowl
  1. Directions:
  2. You will need to pop 24 cups of popcorn. We love to use our Stir Crazy popcorn popper it gives the popcorn a great flavor and crunchy texture. We do add a pinch of salt to each batch, but do not butter it. But you can use plain or buttered popcorn for this recipe, we just prefer plain. Once you have popped your popcorn, measure out 24 cups and set aside while you make the caramel sauce. I would recommend fluffing your popcorn to try and get all the corn kernels that did not pop to sink to the bottom. Toss those in the trash, so you don’t bust your tooth on them (yes my husband has done that more than once).
  3. This makes a BIG batch of popcorn, 24 cups. I love the Thatsa Mega Tupperware Bowl for this recipe. It is big enough to hold everything and allows me to stir and mix without popcorn falling out over the sides.
  4. In a Sauce pot 6 quart or larger add your sweetened Condensed Milk, butter, brown sugar and marshmallows. Over medium heat stir still they are well blended and just come to a low boil. Normally takes about 6-7 minutes. Make sure you do this over medium heat if your temperature is too high your sugar will not dissolve which gives you a gritty texture. I always stir the whole time to prevent scorching the butter and milk.
  5. Once it has come to a low boil, take off heat. Stir in your vanilla (pure vanilla is best) and sprinkle in the baking soda. Do this in a dusting motion so you do not get a big clump of baking soda in your caramel sauce. Be aware that the baking soda will cause your caramel sauce to double in size and become soft, almost foamy. Stir in well then quickly pour over the popcorn you have waiting for you in a bowl.
  6. It will be a bit sticky so I recommend using a Silicone spatula to mix it all together really well. DO NOT try to eat it right away because it is hot! Give it a few minutes to cool down. You can eat it right out of the bowl. Or you can pour it onto a Aluminum Commercial Baker’s Half Sheet. Then as it cools you can cut it into Soft Creamy Caramel Popcorn squares. You can also shape them into Soft Creamy Caramel Popcorn balls.
  7. The caramel is super soft at first this is our favorite time to eat it. After an hour or so it starts to firm up and is still soft, just more like a soft and chewy rice crispy treat that will hold its shape. But still soft and you can easily pull it apart and eat it. It really is amazing! I love that you can make it a few days before an event and it is still delicious!
  8. Try this Soft Creamy Caramel Popcorn Recipe out, let me know what you think. I hope you enjoy it as much as my family does! Perfect for large groups or family movie night!
Soft Creamy Caramel Popcorn Recipe (2024)

FAQs

Why is my caramel popcorn not crunchy? ›

The longer you cook the syrup (the mixture of sugar and water the forms the base of the caramel sauce), the crunchier your popcorn will be. For very crunchy popcorn (my favorite!), stop cooking when you see the first wisps of smoke coming from the sugar mixture.

Why is my homemade caramel popcorn soggy? ›

Give it some time to cool. If it's still tasting soggy after 1–2 hours of cooling at room temperature, you may have under-baked the caramel corn. 1 hour in the oven is usually plenty. Additionally, be sure to cook the caramel on the stove for long enough.

How do you make soft caramel popcorn crispy again? ›

The easiest way to refresh leftover popcorn is to toss it in the oven to warm it up and re-crisp it. Simply spread it out in an even layer on a baking sheet and place it in a 250°F oven for about five minutes, until it's warmed through.

What thickens homemade caramel? ›

To thicken a caramel sauce, use one tablespoon of cornstarch or tapioca starch (sometimes known as tapioca flour) and one tablespoon of water per cup of caramel. Then simmer the caramel, stirring it constantly with a wooden spoon until it becomes thick.

What can I use instead of baking soda in caramel? ›

There are several pantry-friendly ingredients that you can use as baking soda substitutes, including egg whites, self-rising flour and even club soda.

Why put egg in caramel popcorn? ›

While some people said that she added the egg to absorb extra heat, others had different views. "Whole eggs absorb excess heat so it's an easy way to regulate the temperature balance of the other ingredients," a user wrote.

Why is caramel popcorn unhealthy? ›

Caramel popcorn is typically high in calories, sugar, and fat, which can contribute to weight gain and increase your risk for developing health conditions such as diabetes, heart disease, and high blood pressure.

What does an egg do in caramel popcorn? ›

The egg stays in the whole time till the popcorn pops. After the popcorn is plated, the burnt egg is removed. Some Twitter users said that the egg was added as a way to regulate temperatures, while others said that it was just put in to get people wondering what the hell it was doing there.

What makes caramel more runny? ›

To thin caramel, just add some cream or water over heat. Melt caramel loaves in the oven. You can also add corn syrup or lemon juice to caramel sauces to prevent them from crystallizing.

Why does my caramel keep hardening? ›

The water evaporates, leaving sugar crystals behind. If even one sugar crystal falls back into the pan of cooking caramel, it starts a chain reaction of sugar crystals and the entire pan will harden.

How long will homemade caramel popcorn last? ›

How long does Caramel Popcorn Last? After Caramel Popcorn has cooled, store it in an airtight container. When stored in an air-tight container, homemade Caramel Popcorn will be good for up to five days.

How do you make popcorn soft and fluffy? ›

A good lid is important when making popcorn, but there's a bit of a strategy here. For the best results, and lowest number of un-popped kernels leave the lid open just a hairline amount. It allows any steam or moisture to get out as well, resulting in fluffy kernels.

Why baking soda in caramel popcorn? ›

The baking soda reacts with the acid in the recipe (i.e., brown sugar) to create an airier, more brittle texture that's not as sticky as the recipes without it. The charms of caramel corn finally made sense. Once coated, the popcorn goes into the oven for about half an hour.

Can you crisp up caramel popcorn? ›

Once coated, spread the popcorn on a baking sheet lined with parchment paper. If you prefer chewy caramel corn, let it sit until the caramel has hardened. If you prefer crunchy caramel corn, Preheat oven to 250 F. and bake for 30-40 minutes, tossing occasionally.

Does baking soda speed up caramelization? ›

Baking soda makes the onions more alkaline, which speeds up the browning reactions necessary for properly caramelized onions. But it also weakens the pectin that holds the onion's cells together, turning what should be soft but distinct pieces of browned onion into a nauseating stew of pea-green mush.

What happens when you add baking soda to hot sugar? ›

You will observe the sugar and baking soda mixture bubbling and also turning black in colour. As the mixture burns further, it will start to take the form of a snake.

What does adding more baking soda do? ›

Too much baking soda in a recipe can give your baked goods a metallic or soapy taste, so be careful with your amounts in conversions. As a rule of thumb, 1 teaspoon of baking powder is equivalent to ¼ teaspoon of baking soda in terms of leavening power.

References

Top Articles
Lemon and Goat Cheese Ravioli Recipe | Cook the Book
Coconut Milk Chocolate Mousse Recipe - Best Vegan Keto Dessert
Cars & Trucks - By Owner near Kissimmee, FL - craigslist
Terrorist Usually Avoid Tourist Locations
Wizard Build Season 28
Gunshots, panic and then fury - BBC correspondent's account of Trump shooting
Bluegabe Girlfriend
Bhad Bhabie Shares Footage Of Her Child's Father Beating Her Up, Wants Him To 'Get Help'
City Of Spokane Code Enforcement
WK Kellogg Co (KLG) Dividends
Luciipurrrr_
The Binding of Isaac
Mlb Ballpark Pal
Craigslist Alabama Montgomery
6th gen chevy camaro forumCamaro ZL1 Z28 SS LT Camaro forums, news, blog, reviews, wallpapers, pricing – Camaro5.com
Apne Tv Co Com
Haunted Mansion Showtimes Near Millstone 14
Napa Autocare Locator
Everything We Know About Gladiator 2
Khiara Keating: Manchester City and England goalkeeper convinced WSL silverware is on the horizon
Der Megatrend Urbanisierung
Pinellas Fire Active Calls
Kamzz Llc
Pickswise Review 2024: Is Pickswise a Trusted Tipster?
Invitation Homes plans to spend $1 billion buying houses in an already overheated market. Here's its presentation to investors setting out its playbook.
Walgreens Bunce Rd
Boxer Puppies For Sale In Amish Country Ohio
Sand Dollar Restaurant Anna Maria Island
Violent Night Showtimes Near Amc Dine-In Menlo Park 12
Times Narcos Lied To You About What Really Happened - Grunge
10-Day Weather Forecast for Santa Cruz, CA - The Weather Channel | weather.com
Darktide Terrifying Barrage
Filmy Met
Soiza Grass
In Branch Chase Atm Near Me
Skroch Funeral Home
Nacho Libre Baptized Gif
Back to the Future Part III | Rotten Tomatoes
Reading Craigslist Pa
Dynavax Technologies Corp (DVAX)
Omaha Steaks Lava Cake Microwave Instructions
303-615-0055
The All-New MyUMobile App - Support | U Mobile
Flipper Zero Delivery Time
888-822-3743
Energy Management and Control System Expert (f/m/d) for Battery Storage Systems | StudySmarter - Talents
BCLJ July 19 2019 HTML Shawn Day Andrea Day Butler Pa Divorce
Ratchet And Clank Tools Of Destruction Rpcs3 Freeze
Sams Gas Price San Angelo
Theater X Orange Heights Florida
Unit 4 + 2 - Concrete and Clay: The Complete Recordings 1964-1969 - Album Review
How Did Natalie Earnheart Lose Weight
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Pres. Carey Rath

Last Updated:

Views: 5975

Rating: 4 / 5 (41 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Pres. Carey Rath

Birthday: 1997-03-06

Address: 14955 Ledner Trail, East Rodrickfort, NE 85127-8369

Phone: +18682428114917

Job: National Technology Representative

Hobby: Sand art, Drama, Web surfing, Cycling, Brazilian jiu-jitsu, Leather crafting, Creative writing

Introduction: My name is Pres. Carey Rath, I am a faithful, funny, vast, joyous, lively, brave, glamorous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.